True Confessions

I broke up my brother-in-law and his girlfriend

Woman's Day reader
Sunday, September 27, 2009
Win $200 — submit your own true confession via the feedback form at the top of this confession. Those confessions featured on the website will receive $200.
Woman's Day reader
I had been dating my now-husband for nearly two years when I finally met his brother's long term girlfriend. She lived in South Korea and we had always missed each other during her various trips to Australia. I was really looking forward to meeting her, thinking about how our children would probably grow up as cousins, and how we'd enjoy many shared Christmases and holidays together for years to come.

I walked in the door, stuck out my hand and smiled broadly, introducing myself. She paused, stared at the ceiling, and reluctantly proffered a limp hand, mumbling something that may have been 'hi' beneath her breath. I felt as though I'd been slapped across the face. What had I done to deserve such rudeness? I honestly had no idea.

Despite the fact that my husband's mother had cooked up an amazing meal to celebrate the day we had all finally met, Sara behaved like a spoilt child the entire day. She refused to speak to us, ignoring our questions and rolling her eyes at our conversation. At the same time, she chatted happily with my husband's parents, so we knew that we were clearly the ones at whom her behaviour was aimed. Eventually, she disappeared off into the upstairs bedrooms and didn't return.

We were baffled. My husband, who had always gotten on well with her, couldn't understand it. I was personally devastated as I had always gotten along well with my brother-in-law and really wanted to have a good relationship with the woman who was likely to become his wife.

The week that followed was stressful and upsetting as we tried to speak with my brother-in-law and Sara about why she had been so rude. Eventually, we discovered that it was all based in jealousy about our engagement and upcoming wedding. As Sara had been dating my brother-in-law for almost seven years, she felt that the occasion should have been hers.

Our attempts to resolve the situation were fruitless, culminating in an email from Sara that abused me and my husband personally, while making threats that she would 'take us down'. I simply couldn't understand how a grown woman could behave like such a spoilt, childish teenager.

Our wedding was a few short weeks later. To our relief, she didn't come as she was back in South Korea. Instead, my husband and I plotted to get rid of her. I had six single, attractive and fun friends coming along, so I told them all about the situation and how lovely my brother-in-law was but how horrible his girlfriend was, and asked them if they'd consider paying him some 'extra' attention. We then all took the opportunity throughout the day to ply him with copious amounts of champagne, to the extent that he could barely manage to deliver his best man's speech.

By the end of the evening, one of my friends made the move and I pounced, camera in hand, as she started kissing him.

One short email with attachments in reply to the one she sent us was all it took, and the relationship was over. Three months down the track, my brother-in-law isn't speaking to us, and while I do feel bad for causing him pain, I honestly believe that he would have been miserable with her for the rest of his life. Most amazingly, my husbands' parents supported us in what we had done. We could all see that he's a great guy, and she's a psycho. Hopefully one day he'll forgive us, and will see we meant only for the best.

Names have been changed. Picture posed by models.

Your say: Have your say about this true confession below...

User comments
I completely agree with the other comments. What a pathetic, mean spirited, nasty and manipulative person you are. No matter how she behaved towards you, you didn't have any right to interfere in someone else's relationship, even if it wasn't a good one. Do you really blame your brother in law for not speaking to you? Oh well, there is such a thing as karma....what goes around, comes around.
I don't think you can brand the woman a psycho from one meeting, or even one heated email. Maybe your BIL and she had had an argument just prior to your meeting. Maybe some other incident spurred her behaviour. Even if she truly was completely crazy, there are other things you could have done. Up until I read that you actually spent your wedding day waiting for an opportunity to ruin his relationship, I thought you were being reasonable - or if your plan had been to show your BIL how many lovely women there are that wouldn't act like his girlfriend, then that would have been different. What's done is done, and if you're comfortable with your actions then that's all that matters from your point of view, but the ends doesn't always justify the means in my book.
What a piece of work you are - maybe you wanted to cause trouble from the outset due to your own jealousy. To set up your brother in law at your wedding is reprehensible and the fact that you were bent on being vindictive at your wedding rather than rejoicing in the moment says a lot about you. Pity your poor husband - if I were your brother in law I would shun you. Take a good hard look at your motivations - you have behaved very badly.
Who are you to decide who your brother in law marries? I don't blame him for no longer speaking to you. He could never trust you again. If they weren't right for each other they would have sorted it out themselves. I bet none of your friends you ask to flirt with him were Asian. They had been going out for seven years yet you destroyed what seemed to be a strong relationship. You should be ashamed. It's busy bodies like you that have preconcieved ideas about who people should marry that cause all the troubles in relationships. What's your next move? Will all your friends have do get you to vet their boyfriends in case you don't like them?

Write a comment
Email: *
Your email will not be shared with any third parties or published with your comment.
Nickname: *
Location: *

Subject:
*
Comment:
*
Maximum characters 1000

Comment guidelines
Avoid using:
  • Personal attacks
  • Irrelevant comments
  • HTML tags
  • Personal information
  • Offensive language
  • Text in ALL CAPITAL LETTERS
See full comment guidelines
Comment guidelines X
Thank you for sharing your opinions with other users of NineMSN. People will find your comments more helpful if you include relevant information and avoid some common pitfalls.
Please note: All reviews and comments submitted are subject to moderation, NineMSN reserves the right to alter and / or remove any content that does not comply with usage guidelines.
What to include in your comment:
  • A title that briefly summarizes the opinion expressed in the comment.
  • Additional comments adding more detail.
  • Comparisons to other similar products, if this is relevant.
  • To create a new paragraph, press the Enter key twice.
What not to include:
  • Information that will quickly go out of date.
  • Comments on other comments or commenters.
  • Language that other users may find offensive.
  • comments of one sentence or less. Provide information to support your opinion.
  • Personal information like your email address or telephone number.
  • HTML coding. Tags like <b> or <i> will not be recognized.
VOTE
advertisement
advertisement

VIDEOS

PHOTOS

ARTICLES

Valentine's Day - Hollywood's Happiest CouplesValentine's Day - Hollywood's Happiest Couples Katy Perry Will Perform at GrammysKaty Perry Will Perform at Grammys Celebrities Pay Tribute to Whitney HoustonCelebrities Pay Tribute to Whitney Houston

Today's top 5

Billy Bob Thornton: I will always love AngelinaBilly Bob Thornton: I will always love AngelinaAngelina Jolie's ex-husband Billy Bob Thornton clearly still has a soft spot for her, saying he will "love her until the end of my life". Nicole and Tom's war over IsabellaNicole and Tom's war over IsabellaThe furious actress hits LA to demand a meeting with her ex-husband over their daughter’s looming marriage to Eddie Frencher. Kate and William's kidnap terrorKate and William's kidnap terrorFears for the safety of Prince William and his wife are at an all-time high as the pair’s security is labelled ‘incompetent’. Devoted husband sends a love letter for his wife to Woman's DayDevoted husband sends a love letter for his wife to Woman's DayWhen Todd Hobson asked us to help out his sick wife, he was in for a surprise of his own. NRL cougar Charmyne Palavi becomes a grandmotherNRL cougar Charmyne Palavi becomes a grandmotherShe famously dated young footballers, but now the blonde beauty is smitten by a far younger bloke – her first grandchild.

Your say

Most commented

Sara Leonardi-McGrath: Our family joySara Leonardi-McGrath: Our family joyIt is never too soon or too late to remarry but Mc Grath has made a disastrous decision with Leonardi He doesn't expect such negative reactions from the public because he thought that he could easily sell her image and pocket big money with the popularity of his unfortunate late wife Wrong honey Its not that easy!!!!! I dont know her personally but via her interviews and tweets everybody can see that she is a loathsome arrogant pretentious ridiculous and stupid person . Its her life but she should shut her large mouth and stop promoting herself in magazines or tweetsr if she doesnt want to read bad crictics from the publicfrank, bondi18 CommentsPost commentView comments
Sara Leonardi-McGrath: Our family joySara Leonardi-McGrath: Our family joyIt is never too soon or too late to remarry but Mc Grath has made a disastrous decision with Leonardi He doesn't expect such negative reactions from the public because he thought that he could easily sell her image and pocket big money with the popularity of his unfortunate late wife Wrong honey Its not that easy!!!!! I dont know her personally but via her interviews and tweets everybody can see that she is a loathsome arrogant pretentious ridiculous and stupid person . Its her life but she should shut her large mouth and stop promoting herself in magazines or tweetsr if she doesnt want to read bad crictics from the publicfrank, bondi18 CommentsPost commentView comments Mel B is new host on Dancing with the StarsMel B is new host on Dancing with the StarsWell you aint gonna get my support DWTS - I dont like Mel B one bit, what is wrong with getting a good looking aussie girl to host the show? Mel B is a has been, she is no longer famous. Stop giving our jobs away!Boo, QLD18 CommentsPost commentView comments Unhappy housewifeTrue Confessions Agony Aunt: My husband and kids take me for grantedAh women attacking women yet again. So much for the sisterhood. I am a stay at home Mum. I do not "bludge" off my husband. I manage the house, the meals, the money and everyone's schedules. I do not have a "clock off" time. But I do have break times. When my son is at school and my baby boy is asleep I can put my feet up, read a book etc. I do make time for myself and yes I do complain sometimes especially when I am tired. My husband also comes home from work and complains about his job sometimes. Everybody has a right to have a bit of a whinge regardless of the choices they made in life. I love my role and despite some complaints from me there are also many rich rewards. I have not missed a moment of my baby's life so far, I get to help my older boy with his homework and be involved with his life. If you feel unappreciated speak up. I do if I feel I am being taken for granted. Your job is so important and you desrve some respect even if you don't bring in a wage.Ads, Vermont Vic16 CommentsPost commentView comments Nicole Kidman's panic: I've lost my baby girlNicole Kidman's panic: I've lost my baby girlIts a shame there are so many misconceptions about Scientology. Perhaps some want it that way. I have been in it for may years on and get annoyed by the stuff written about it. The media like to sell their magazines by creating controversy about the religion and the celebs that belong to it. One also wonders if vested interests who want to put Scientology out of business because of its genuine stance against pharmaceutical drugging of kids and abuse of human rights might be financing some of these attacks. Scientology is about spiritual awareness. Something that I feel this society is short of. Especially when a society seems to be rife with magazines full of gosip based not nessecarily on fact but what someone thinks people want to hear. Good luck to the happy couple and if it doesnt work out then good luck to both of them anyway. StanStan the Man, Adelaide14 CommentsPost commentView comments NRL cougar Charmyne Palavi becomes a grandmotherNRL cougar Charmyne Palavi becomes a grandmotherEducate your children, STOP feeding them rubbish, STOP chasing youth in yourself as it's long gone and in your partners, STOP posting immoral rantings on FB for your children to see and STOP playing the victim! You might just find there is a whole world out there beyond teenage pregnancies, fake tans and McDonald's!!well travelled, Sydney13 CommentsPost commentView comments