True Confessions

True Confessions Agony Aunt: My abortion turmoil and my sister

True Confessions Agony Aunt
Sunday, December 19, 2010
Woman suffering
Woman suffering

Question:

My sister told me she can't have children just weeks after I had an abortion and now I’m in turmoil.

Trying to support my heartbroken sister and cope with my own feelings of guilt and loss has left me ill, but when I first made the decision I thought it was the right one.

I’ve never wanted children and the boyfriend I had was a total lightweight, but a lot of fun. I got pregnant completely by accident and my doctor still doesn’t know how it happened because I never missed a pill, was never sick or had a stomach upset.

I couldn’t believe it at first and when I told my boyfriend he nearly hit the road there and then so I knew he had no interest in a baby.

In the end I had an abortion and told him I hadn’t been pregnant after all because I didn’t want him telling anyone else.

Then my sister turned up in floods. She and her husband had been trying to have a baby for six years and have now been told it’s practically impossible that she will conceive.

They’ve tried various procedures but apparently now there’s no hope of conceiving naturally. They’ve spent thousands of dollars trying to conceive and have nearly bankrupted themselves, so they have to give up, with nothing to show for it.

I feel so guilty - I can barely look at her because I do actually feel quite bad about the abortion although I didn’t think I would.

If she had even told me a few weeks ago I could maybe have had the baby and she could have adopted it and I keep wondering if I should suggest having a baby for her, though I could never tell her about the abortion.

Answer:

There are two separate issues here but it’s almost impossible for you to separate them from each other because they deal with the same subject.

You made your decision based on your own circumstances and while it seems tragically unfair that you ended up pregnant when you didn’t want to and didn’t plan to, that doesn’t affect your sister’s situation at all, other than how you cope with it.

This is not the time to be considering having a baby for her, if ever, not least because you are still so sad over what happened to you.

You have to be very brave in dealing with her and try to put the abortion out of your mind, which is not easy. Your sister could still adopt or foster a child but at present she has to come to terms with the fact that she might never get pregnant.

While she is grieving over this you are grieving over your abortion which is made harder by being unable to share it with her or anyone else. It could help if you go back to your doctor or the clinic and ask for counselling; if nothing else you will at least be able to talk to someone about how you feel and also tell them how much worse it is because of your sister’s experience.

They won’t judge you because if nothing else, they do know that an abortion is not something many people could opt for lightly and they recognise that no matter what your reasons, you are still suffering and could be for some time.

If you can accept that you need help to get over your situation then you might find it a little easier to offer support to your sister but do not rush into any decisions at all on her behalf – simply be there for her and don’t neglect your own needs.

Picture posed by model.

Your say:

Do you have advice on this problem? Please share your thoughts in the comments section below...

User comments
I really wanted to comment back to you because I don't think you completely understand all the circumstances around abortion can be a good thing for womens right and choices. I am currently pregnant with my second child, after 2 years of trying. There's nothing I want more than this baby, HOWEVER...this will HAVE to be my last pregnancy. My body would not support either me or a further pregnancy to the point it could actually kill us BOTH. Are you suggesting I should kill myself, when I have a choice? How could I ever do that to my husband or other kids? More over, did you also know that getting tubes tied or other permanent options are NOT easy to request? Some hospitals in fact won't allow the procedure under their roof! Everyone should have the right to decide these things for themselves without fear of recrimination from people like you. To the woman in the story, good luck to you and your family, I hope you all find happiness.
I am in the same situation. I can't have children, and my sister has had an abortion. It kills me everytime I think about it, but not because I wanted her child because I disagree with abortion. It's never the answer -- and to those who say it's a choice. I'm sorry but killing something with a heartbeat is illegal. So don't gloss over it. That aside, I support women who have had abortions to work through the issues. I prefer to fight the cause of abortion rather than bash those who have them. If you don't want the baby give it up so someone who desperate does want one can have it. Just remember abortion is never the answer, but try not to feel guilt over your decision now -- it's done. You cannot change it now, I would never make my sister feel guilty over her own.
My story sounds a bit like yours. I was seeing this guy and we both knew it was not serious but silly me fell pregnant. Yes not taking the correct protections for this decision. Anyway i was too young and had an abortion. Never told him and a year later he met and married his love. All is well until a few years go by and they find out they cant have children. bad timing i am guessing but still like yourself a decision that we will live with. It was the wrong time i just guess
You need to stop thinking about your sister and start thinking about yourself. If you had found out about your sisters issue when you were still pregnant, and had decided to keep the baby for her, could you live with knowing that the child she was raising is acctually yours? You say you dont want children now but whose to say your maternal insticts wouldnt have kicked in after giving birth. Then you have a situation of either keeping the baby and hurting your sister more with false hope or giving it up and constantly being reminded of what you have lost. You are better off letting your sister adopt a child with no connection to you so you know where you stand. Dont feel bad. Its your life and your body just like its your sisters life and her problem. Help her if you want but think carefully about what you are doing and dont do it out of guilt, do it out of love.
You and only you can make that decision. Abortion is a personal choice that only one person can make, the person who is pregnant. I don't believe in abortion but would not force my views on anyone else as it is not my right nor my body. Don't beat yourself up. You made the decision that was best for you at the time.
Seriously...why feel guilty? You didn't want a baby. It was your choice to have an abortion. You shouldn't feel upset about your sister's predicament. She can adopt a baby. There are lots of children in the world who need a Mum. She can adopt. Don't feel bad. What would have happened when you had a baby you did not want? How could you give it the full love that way? Don't feel bad.
Get over it. Abortion is legalised.All of you who are bashing this woman over her choice is ridiculous. DID you not read she was taking contraception???? Her doctor even said he was unsure of how she got pregnant? You just seem to go on the attack about her choice to get an abortion because u dont agree. Since when can you judge this person? Have you walked in her shoes? Have you been in that situation? WHO ARE YOU to judge her circumstance? Get off your high morale,or so you think, and see the real issue that this story is discussing, the guilt she feels between her and her sister. Obviously you have an opinion - but keep it to yourself. Noone wants to her you bashing someone over making the hard choice over an abortion. Its not your situation to judge because you are not in it! Abortion is a choice, and its a single womans choice. While I understand your view, if she is under no circumstance in a position to raise a child, which would be fatherless and struggle. Did u think of that?
I know you must be feeling alot of emotion at the moment, but try to look at the facts here. Your sister cannot have a baby but is desperate to have one, you can obviously get pregnant but don't want to. Well, would you consider being a surrogate for your sister? I do not know why you didn't consider this before the abortion - I personally would have looked at all the options beforehand - but that is me. I think instead of telling her what you did, tell you are all checked out and in good working order, and offer yourself to surrogate, that is if you are willing to.
You made what you believed was the right decision at the time so you need to forgive yourself. Being there to help your sister is the important thing right now for both of you.
if you read the artical correctly you will note that it is stated "I got pregnant completely by accident and my doctor still doesn’t know how it happened because I never missed a pill, was never sick or had a stomach upset" so maybe you are the SILLY GIRL. I dont beleive in abortions but everyone has to make choices in THEIR LIFE not yours not anyone elses

VOTE
advertisement
advertisement

VIDEOS

PHOTOS

ARTICLES

Amanda Bynes Shares Topless PhotosAmanda Bynes Shares Topless Photos Kim Kardashian Flaunts Pregnant Bikini Body in GreeceKim Kardashian Flaunts Pregnant Bikini Body in Greece Demi Moore a Rocks Bikini at Harry Morton's Family HouseDemi Moore a Rocks Bikini at Harry Morton's Family House

Today's top 5

Why Arnold and Maria still haven’t divorcedWhy Arnold and Maria still haven’t divorcedArnold Schwarzenegger and Maria Shriver had one of the most shocking celebrity break-ups of all time, but the two are in no rush to make their divorce official. Bon Jovi says his daughter’s overdose was “horrible”Bon Jovi says his daughter’s overdose was “horrible”Rock star Jon Bon Jovi has opened up, revealing his “worst moment as a father” was the day his 19-year-old daughter overdosed on heroin in November last year Ashton Kutcher meets Mila Kunis' parentsAshton Kutcher meets Mila Kunis' parentsWhile his divorce proceedings with estranged wife Demi Moore seem to be moving at a snail’s pace, Ashton Kutcher’s relationship with girlfriend Mila Kunis is picking up speed. Natalie Bassingthwaighte welcomes second childNatalie Bassingthwaighte welcomes second childNatalie Bassingthwaighte has welcomed her second child, a son named Hendrix John Hickson McGlinchey. Royal wedding joy: Beatrice is engaged!Royal wedding joy: Beatrice is engaged!The parents are delighted – now the push for a ceremony fit for a princess.

Your say

Most commented

I took my sister’s child away from herI took my sister’s child away from herwow....!!!!!????, oh26 CommentsPost commentView comments Another MKR hot hook-up!Another MKR hot hook-up!Vinny Jones from Sydney - I personally think the Spice Girls were not nasty and vicious as Sophia and Ashlee. I really do think the Spice Girls were very inmature and silly young ladies, but they were not nasty and vicious like those 2 Cabramatta girls. Fancy them saying after they did not win at the Sydney markets that they would have done a better job of making the Vietnamese Pork Rolls, that the brother and sister team won in that challenge. Sophia and Ashlee must have seen green that day, with smoke coming out of their ears. SUFFER. Obviously you both think you can do better, but the public that came for lunch at the market didn't think so. You live and learn.anniepoo, Melbourne10 CommentsPost commentView comments Who wore it better Kim or Robin Williams?Who wore it better Kim K or Robin Williams?Kim's dress is disgusting, WAY too much floral print. If the dress was sleeveless with a lower neckline and a bottom hem that finished above the knee, it may have looked a little better. It looks like she threw grandma's curtains over her and walked out the door!!Chantelle, Sydney10 CommentsPost commentView comments Michelle Bridges stole my husbandMichelle Bridges stole my husbandWho cares whether Michelle is 43 or 50 years old. This is a very immature thing to do. Of course he is only thinking with his old fella instead of his brain as he sure doesn't give a damn about his kids. Michelle does not have any so she don't care. Both should go off quietly together as they are both pathetic.Pip, NSw10 CommentsPost commentView comments Mahalia Barnes transformed: I'm half my size!Mahalia Barnes transformed: I'm half my size!I agree 100%. Well done Mahalia, you look wonderful and are an inspiration to your daughter & lots of other women. But how ridiculous to suggest she is a size 8-10, I weigh 68 Kilos and being10cm taller I'm pretty confident I'm slimmer through the torso - but no way can I fit into an 8, a 10 maybe if its not too fitted.Chaz, Adelaide5 CommentsPost commentView comments