Christmas

I lied to my family to escape their Christmas chaos

Woman's Day reader
Friday, December 21, 2012
I lied to my family to escape their Christmas chaos
"I can't believe my only daughter won't even make the effort for me on Christmas Day." I knew they were both being totally unreasonable but awash with pregnancy hormones I spent the whole of Christmas day in tears and Paul reached the end of his tether, swearing that from now on Christmas would only be on our terms...
Woman's Day reader
Topics:
Christmas
My husband Paul and I have got a lot in common, especially when it comes to our mothers. There's no way to put this politely as the honest truth is that they're demanding, overbearing and experts at emotional blackmail.

Unfortunately when we got married that just added competitive to the mix as they tussled over us like two dogs with a bone and Christmas became a nightmare of unreasonable demands. Both our dads had the sense to stay out of it, but our mothers expected us to spend Christmas Day with them and paid no attention to our plaintive pleas to try and have a peaceful Christmas.

"I need my family round me on Christmas Day. I don't ask for much but that's all it takes to make me happy," announced my mother.

Meanwhile, Paul's was weeping down the phone to him, claiming inexplicably that for all anyone knew, this could be her last Christmas and "Is it too much to ask my only son to make the effort?"

We should really have stood up to them but that first Christmas we decided to make the effort, telling his family that we'd be with them for Christmas lunch and my family that we'd reach them for Christmas dinner.

Despite the two-hour drive needed for each visit it would have been just manageable had either mother recognised the effort we put in, but in the event his mother moaned that we didn't spend long enough with them and mine went on about us eating so much lunch we didn't do justice to her lovely dinner.

Fed up, totally hot and bothered and feeling that Christmas was a dead loss, we started our third two-hour drive of the day feeling completely disgruntled.

By the time we got back to our own house we were shattered and grumpy — Christmas was hell. This went on for three years, with neither of us plucking up enough courage to stand up to our mothers, but by the fourth Christmas we were seeing the light at the end of the tunnel.

I was eight months pregnant and we promised each other that next Christmas would be in our own home with our baby. On Christmas Eve I started feeling more and more unwell and Paul took me to the hospital, where I was firmly told to put my feet up for the next few days as I was going nowhere.

It was very hot, my blood pressure was up and my feet and legs were swelling badly so the last thing I needed was hours travelling in the car.

Paul rushed out to buy some food and I phoned both mothers to tell them what the doctor had said. Their reactions were almost identical and equally unbelievable. "Never mind me then," said Paul's mother and my own was even more dramatic, saying "I can't believe my only daughter won't even make the effort for me on Christmas Day."

I knew they were both being totally unreasonable but awash with pregnancy hormones I spent the whole of Christmas Day in tears and Paul reached the end of his tether, swearing that from now on Christmas would only be on our terms, something we felt even more strongly about when Carrie was born a month later.

The following year we took a week's holiday just before Christmas, renting a little holiday home 300km away and telling our families we would be back on Christmas Eve.

Instead, we packed the car with all the food and drink needed for a fabulous week including Christmas dinner and all the presents for Carrie's first Christmas and headed off.

When we got there we phoned our mothers from the local pub and said that there was no mobile signal but we wanted them to know we had arrived safely and were having a wonderful time.

On Christmas Eve we put Carrie in the pram, strolled down to the pub and phoned both mothers to tell them that the car had broken down and we couldn't get rescue services till the 27th, but not to worry as we'd managed to get food from the village shop so we were just going to relax and make the most of it.

We were stifling giggles as we said it was such a shame about missing Christmas Day with everyone and of course there was no way we'd let anyone drive that distance to get us, see you all soon, have a lovely time.

Safe in the knowledge that no-one knew exactly where we were we ambled back to the little house and had the most peaceful, blissful Christmas, no-one telling us what to do or making a fuss over nothing.

Ever since then we've had Christmas by ourselves at home with Carrie and now with her little brother Conor though anyone who wants to join us on Boxing Day is very welcome.

Your say: Have you had a similar experience? Share your stories and thoughts below.

Earn $200 — submit your own true confession via the feedback form at the top of this confession. Those confessions featured on the website will receive $200.
User comments
Congratulations on having resolved your problem so delicately! Some parents practise "selfish" love.. Sad that you had to suffer so long beforehand.
What would you do if your mother and mother in law insisted that you come to Christmas on Christmas day, refused to compromise and made you miserable the whole time? probably the same thing People only see what they want to see in the story that two adults don't want to spend time with their families on Christmas. However a lot of you going "You should communicate with them", "Stand up to their emotional blackmail" and "Wow, you are SO ungreatful." Have failed to see a very important part of the story, the straw that broke the camels back for this woman. She was 8 months pregant and ORDERED BY A DOCTOR TO STAY AT HOME. When they comunicated this to both mothers, both of them were more concerned with themselves and their Christmas. Not one of them said "Are you ok? Is the baby ok? I understand." And as for trying to compromise, She tried but each mother insisted they see them on Christmas day. Personally, I would do the same thing if my family was that much of a nightmare.
I should also have said, to those who claim not to understand why you lied, you are perfectly entitled to deal with these womens' appalling selfishness in any way you choose. Personally, I would have told them the truth, but nobody has the right to judge how you deal with their abusive treatment. Well done again for getting out from under these dreadful women, and taking back your absolute right to do as you please with your own family.
Well done you. If people behave selfishly and appallingly, as both your mothers did, you are under absolutely no obligation to enable them. Just sorry you put up with their blackmailing bullying for as long as you did. Great that you are both on the same page about this too and backing each other up, as bullying blackmail from parents can put a strain on a marriage. Hope you had a great festive season.
I used to be one of those people that used to rush from one family to another dragging all the kids along every Christmas just trying to keep the peace. When I actually became a Grandma I told my kids that from now on I never wanted them to have to go through what I went through as a young Mum. We organised it so everyone would be my house for either Christmas lunch or dinner on Christmas Eve. That way they could spend Christmas day alone with their own children. They would then all go to their respective in laws for Boxing Day. Everyone is happy and this has now been going on smoothly for 8 years. All the in laws are happy too as it has made their lives easier too as they know they will have time with their family without the stress.
You put your foot down lady & don't take any of the blackmailing nonsense from either mother or mother in law. That's all it takes. Lunch at one place one year, dinner at the other - then swap about the following year. But you have to be tough about it OR explain to both of them why you are staying away, A police-man friend of mine said their callouts are the heaviest around Xmas. So, if there is no middle ground between your stupid mother & mother-in-law, then stay away and enjoy yourselves.
Selfish, probably spoiled children, that's what you come across as!...shame on you! Just think, one day those children of yours will be ignoring you and avoiding you on Christmas day or other days, wonder how smug you'll be then, all i can say is Im very very glad you're not my kids, who'd want you?!......
I haven't spoken to or seen 3 of my grandchilden for 9 years and Christmas is a very lonely time for me. My one wish is that my son and his partner could get over their differences with me and not penalise my grandchildren because of or differences other son granddaughter has gone to Perth this Christmas to be with his partners daughter hope that they have a lovely Christmas even though I am spending Christmas alone this year again i 'ts just another day for me.
I actually do not really like my family. I also do not care if I do not see them again. Every family is different, every family has a history. Mine is not great. I do not join them for Christmas and it is wonderful. To each their own.
I can't believe how many people are grizzling simply because they are too spineless to be honest with their families! What is wrong with simply saying - "hey, we really can't manage this? Either you can all come to us or we will come to you on alternate years". And if the attempt to send you on a guilt trip arises, simply say "I'm sorry, but please don't try to blackmail me into coming as it will mean we just have a miserable Christmas, you are being really selfish you know. I love you, but it cuts both ways so just take a deep breath and think about it". Personally I'd love to have family to spend Christmas with! My parents are now dead and I only have my brother, so we just go to a restaurant for lunch and invite anyone else who is going to be alone on the day. Be grateful for the blessing of still having your family!

Write a comment
Email: *
Your email will not be shared with any third parties or published with your comment.
Nickname: *
Location: *

Subject:
*
Comment:
*
Maximum characters 1000

Comment guidelines
Avoid using:
  • Personal attacks
  • Irrelevant comments
  • HTML tags
  • Personal information
  • Offensive language
  • Text in ALL CAPITAL LETTERS
See full comment guidelines
Comment guidelines X
Thank you for sharing your opinions with other users of NineMSN. People will find your comments more helpful if you include relevant information and avoid some common pitfalls.
Please note: All reviews and comments submitted are subject to moderation, NineMSN reserves the right to alter and / or remove any content that does not comply with usage guidelines.
What to include in your comment:
  • A title that briefly summarizes the opinion expressed in the comment.
  • Additional comments adding more detail.
  • Comparisons to other similar products, if this is relevant.
  • To create a new paragraph, press the Enter key twice.
What not to include:
  • Information that will quickly go out of date.
  • Comments on other comments or commenters.
  • Language that other users may find offensive.
  • comments of one sentence or less. Provide information to support your opinion.
  • Personal information like your email address or telephone number.
  • HTML coding. Tags like <b> or <i> will not be recognized.
advertisement
advertisement

VIDEOS

PHOTOS

ARTICLES

Amanda Bynes Poses in a Busty Lacy Bra SnapAmanda Bynes Poses in a Busty Lacy Bra Snap Amanda Bynes Arrested After Allegedly Throwing a Bong Out of Her Apartment WindowAmanda Bynes Arrested After Allegedly Throwing a Bong Out of Her Apartment Window Amanda Bynes Shares Topless PhotosAmanda Bynes Shares Topless Photos

Today's top 5

Michelle Bridges confirms she’s dating The CommandoMichelle Bridges confirms she’s dating The CommandoAfter weeks of speculation, The Biggest Loser star Michelle Bridges has confirmed she is in a relationship with her co-star Steve “The Commando” Willis. Madonna lays down the dating laws for LourdesMadonna lays down the dating laws for LourdesMadonna has always had a rebellious streak but she’s certainly strict when it comes to her teenage daughter, Lourdes. Michelle Bridges stole my husbandMichelle Bridges stole my husbandThey may be the most talked about new couple in the country, but a shocking secret lies at the heart of the Biggest Loser’s red-carpet romance. Hazel Hawke dies aged 83Hazel Hawke dies aged 83Former first lady Hazel Hawke has died aged 83. Why Arnold and Maria still haven’t divorcedWhy Arnold and Maria still haven’t divorcedArnold Schwarzenegger and Maria Shriver had one of the most shocking celebrity break-ups of all time, but the two are in no rush to make their divorce official.
Nicole Kidman
Isla Fisher
Who was best dressed at Cannes?
Which star gets your vote for best dressed at this year's Cannes Film Festival?

Your say

Most commented

I took my sister’s child away from herI took my sister’s child away from herwow....!!!!!????, oh26 CommentsPost commentView comments Another MKR hot hook-up!Another MKR hot hook-up!Vinny Jones from Sydney - I personally think the Spice Girls were not nasty and vicious as Sophia and Ashlee. I really do think the Spice Girls were very inmature and silly young ladies, but they were not nasty and vicious like those 2 Cabramatta girls. Fancy them saying after they did not win at the Sydney markets that they would have done a better job of making the Vietnamese Pork Rolls, that the brother and sister team won in that challenge. Sophia and Ashlee must have seen green that day, with smoke coming out of their ears. SUFFER. Obviously you both think you can do better, but the public that came for lunch at the market didn't think so. You live and learn.anniepoo, Melbourne10 CommentsPost commentView comments Who wore it better Kim or Robin Williams?Who wore it better Kim K or Robin Williams?Kim's dress is disgusting, WAY too much floral print. If the dress was sleeveless with a lower neckline and a bottom hem that finished above the knee, it may have looked a little better. It looks like she threw grandma's curtains over her and walked out the door!!Chantelle, Sydney10 CommentsPost commentView comments Michelle Bridges stole my husbandMichelle Bridges stole my husbandWho cares whether Michelle is 43 or 50 years old. This is a very immature thing to do. Of course he is only thinking with his old fella instead of his brain as he sure doesn't give a damn about his kids. Michelle does not have any so she don't care. Both should go off quietly together as they are both pathetic.Pip, NSw9 CommentsPost commentView comments Mahalia Barnes transformed: I'm half my size!Mahalia Barnes transformed: I'm half my size!I agree 100%. Well done Mahalia, you look wonderful and are an inspiration to your daughter & lots of other women. But how ridiculous to suggest she is a size 8-10, I weigh 68 Kilos and being10cm taller I'm pretty confident I'm slimmer through the torso - but no way can I fit into an 8, a 10 maybe if its not too fitted.Chaz, Adelaide5 CommentsPost commentView comments