Family

Expert says texting and Facebook no worse than TV

Friday, October 29, 2010
Getty Images
Many parents today may believe their children have a lot more distractions than what they did as a kid with the invention of Facebook and texting, but is this really the case?

US child psychologist Professor Douglas Gentile says Facebook and texting aren't any better or worse than what today's parents did as teens: watch TV. But he says they do pose greater social risks, such as cyberbullying, the Associated Press reported.

The Iowa State University researcher, who studies the effects of media on children, says texting, Facebook and video games are not inherently bad, nor are they any better than watching TV.

He said parents are struggling to adjust to a new world where kids would rather look at a mobile phone screen than have a conversation or join in on family activities.

"[For] the older generation, it's not their culture. There is a resistance to it," Professor Gentile said.

He said the experience of watching TV as a family is still a "shared experience" with the family. But when I child is texting a friend from school it is it's a "private experience," he said. "It's like they're whispering secrets. And we find it rude."

Professor Gentile said that if a child is brought up around protective factors, which include good teachers, a family that values education, culturally rich experiences or a love for reading, the screen time doesn't really matter.

"If you had all these protective factors, then that one little risk factor of [screen time], who cares?" he said.

One thing parents should worry about though is that these devices are encouraging multitasking, Professor Gentile said.

"Multi-tasking is not really good for anyone," he said. "Your reflexes speed up, you're quicker to look over your shoulder and notice little noises or lights. This is not what they need when they get to the classroom and you're supposed to ignore the kid next to you.

"Scanning to see when the next message comes, this may not be good for kids. The more distractions you have, the worse your performance is. Getting kids to turn off their phones, iPods, and computers in order to concentrate on homework and reading, I think that's a fight worth having."

Related video: Facebook security revamp.

User comments
I noticed that this document failed to mention the other major adverse effect on todays youth. And that is of physical and emotional isolation. Don't get me wrong I am not old by any means.It's just that when I was young,the only way(apart from occassional phone calls) to communicate with people my own age or with friends or family was by direct contact,face to face. I see that the media and "experts" claim that TV is a brain dumbing waste of time and video games promote violence and anti-social behaviour. So why not talk about the problems with facebook and or sms? Where are those stories? Thanks for reading.
Observing my teen daughter's experiences of Facebook so far leads me to think it is a Cancer on Society.. and as the parent I have no rights to have the account deleted unless I can provide US documantation to prove I am the parent. Not easy to do in Australia. There is plenty of good evidence around to show that Media in all it's forms, plus the Bleeding Heart minority groups who pushed for the disempowerment of parents over children, are having a massive desensitizing effect on the younger generations for 30 years now. Remember this push began around 1980. If you want to get a balanced perspective on parenting you need to listen to Dr.Phil speak about Commando Parenting.. if that does not wake you up to what is really happening and what you personally can do about it in your home, then nothing will. And I fear those who cannot see the highly negative slope ech generation is sliding down rapidly towards an explosive situation. This research is biased in favour of the agenda.

advertisement
advertisement

VIDEOS

PHOTOS

ARTICLES

Kim Kardashian is a Bikini Babe in MexicoKim Kardashian is a Bikini Babe in Mexico Weird Anna Nicole Smith nude photos released (video NSFW!)Weird Anna Nicole Smith nude photos released (video NSFW!) Valentine's Day - Hollywood's Happiest CouplesValentine's Day - Hollywood's Happiest Couples

Today's top 5

Why I left my terminally ill wifeWhy I left my terminally ill wifeThe year of my 21st was the worst year of my life. I had been dealt a double blow six months earlier, when my beautiful dad passed away from stomach cancer and my long-time boyfriend broke up with me. Things were financially stretched as I struggled to get myself through my vet science degree. Not your average householdNot your average householdTwo parents and a couple of kids used to be the norm. But these days, thanks to rocketing property prices, all sorts of people find themselves living together. True Confessions Agony Aunt: I hate my StepsonTrue Confessions Agony Aunt: I hate my StepsonBeing a stepmother is my worst nightmare. I never had the desire or yearned children of my own but fell in love with a man who has his son 85 per cent of the time. I thought I could hack it, but I am really at the end of my tether. Bec Hewitt's bump: Baby number four?!Bec Hewitt's bump: Baby number four?!The former soap star seems to be hiding a happy secret under her baggy sweaters I became a stripper to pay my way through universityI became a stripper to pay my way through universityThe year of my 21st was the worst year of my life. I had been dealt a double blow six months earlier, when my beautiful dad passed away from stomach cancer and my long-time boyfriend broke up with me. Things were financially stretched as I struggled to get myself through my vet science degree.
Beyoncé Knowles
Cameron Diaz
Best dressed at the Met Gala 2012
There were some stunning dresses at this year's Met Gala, but which celebrity was best dressed? You decide!